We are grateful to Almighty God for the priests who have faithfully served in our parish over the past 125 years.
We include in this list those who grew up as members of our parish family; those who served us as seminarians and deacons; those who provided summer assistance; those who were in residence in our rectory; and those who were officially assigned to our parish. We ask that you continue to pray daily for these holy men.
| Name | Birthplace | Date Ordained |
| Rev. James J. Ayres | New York City | 5/13/1918 |
| Rev. Andre M. Bain | 2004 | |
| Rev. Emil J. Balutowski | Brooklyn | 6/11/1938 |
| Rev. Thomas Basquel, CSSp. | ||
| Rev. John J. Boardman | Brooklyn | 5/21/1921 |
| Rev. John J. Boyle | 2/13/1988 | |
| Rev. Edmund P. Brady | Queens | 5/30/1959 |
| Rev. John J. Brennan | Brooklyn | 6/1/1912 |
| Rev. Msgr. John J. Brown | ||
| Rev. Stewart R. Brown | Virginia | 4/11/1944 |
| Rev. Michael Buckley, CSSp. | ||
| Rev. Edward A. Bukey | Brooklyn | 6/14/1924 |
| Rev. John F. Bukey | Brooklyn | 12/22/1923 |
| Msgr. Brian F. X. Callaghan | 5/29/1965 | |
| Rev. Thomas P. Campbell | New York City | 4/27/1943 |
| Rev. Bryan J. Carney | Brooklyn | 6/2/2007 |
| Rev. Thomas O. Casey | Brooklyn | 6/14/1924 |
| Rev. William M. Casey | New York | 6/7/1930 |
| Rev. James M. Cavanagh | Brooklyn | 6/7/1952 |
| Rev. Richard A. Chichester | Long Island | 5/18/1940 |
| Rev. Patrick Cleary, CSSp. | ||
| Rev. Michael Conroy | ||
| Rev. Emmet J. Costigan | Brooklyn | 5/31/1947 |
| Very Rev. William F. Cronin, MI | ||
| Rev. Robert E. Crowell | Brooklyn | 6/2/1928 |
| Rev. John F. Cullinane | Brooklyn | 6/2/1956 |
| Rev. James J. D’Amato | Brooklyn | 6/11/1949 |
| Rev. Dwayne D. Davis | Jamaica, West Indies | 6/29/2013 |
| Rev. James Devine, CSSp. | ||
| Rev. Patrick Devine, CSSp. | ||
| Rev. Kevin Dilworth, S.J. | Brooklyn | 6/9/1984 |
| Rev. Jeremiah J. Dineen | Ireland | 5/25/1929 |
| Rev. Thomas V. Doyle | Broad Channel | 5/19/1984 |
| Rev. William R. Dulaney | Queens | 5/26/1973 |
| Rev. Edward W. Dullea | Ireland | 1878 |
| Rev. Clifford C. Ekwueme | ||
| Rev. James H. Ennis | Brooklyn | 12/16/1925 |
| Rev. Benedict Etafo | Nigeria | |
| Rev. Dennis E. Finn | 6/2/1929 | |
| Rev. Charles G. Fliegel | Long Island City | 5/25/1929 |
| Rev. Joseph G. Fonti | 1992 | |
| Rev. Eugene B. Frein | Queens | 6/7/1941 |
| Rev. Joseph A. Gancila | ||
| Rev. A. Peter Gopaul | 6/28/1997 | |
| Rev. James J. Haggarty | Brooklyn | 4/3/1945 |
| Rev. John Harrington | ||
| Rev. Kieran E. Harrington | 6/2/2001 | |
| Rev. John J. Heffernan | 11/14/1943 | |
| Msgr. Denis M. Herron | 1973 | |
| Rev. Anthony L. Holzheimer | Brooklyn | 5/31/1947 |
| Rev. Charles J. Hughes | Rhode Island | 3/15/1919 |
| Rev. Edward M. Kachurka | ||
| Rev. James F. Keenan, S.J. | Brooklyn | 6/12/1982 |
| Rev. James F. Kehoe | Manhattan | 1896 |
| Deacon Kennedy | ||
| Rev. Thomas Kim | Korea | |
| Msgr. Jeremiah J. King | Brooklyn | 1915 |
| Msgr. John B. Lavin | ||
| Rev. Thomas J. Lyons | Brooklyn | 6/7/1952 |
| Msgr. John E. Mahoney | ||
| Msgr. Kieran J. Martin | 6/3/1950 | |
| Rev. Paa Kinesi Masion | Ghana | |
| Rev. William A. McAllister | Brooklyn | 4/16/1930 |
| Rev. Francis X. McHugh | ||
| Rev. James J. McKenna | Brooklyn | 5/30/1942 |
| Rev. John McKenna, CM | 1963 | |
| Rev. James A. McNamara | Canada | 6/15/1935 |
| Rev. Patrick J. McNelis | Brooklyn | 6/2/1962 |
| Rev. George Merolla | ||
| Rev. John C. Miller | 5/20/1995 | |
| Rev. Walter Mitchell | ||
| Rev. Nathan A. Morgan | Brooklyn | 5/1/1918 |
| Rev. Noel Moynahan, CSSp. | ||
| Rev. Michael Mulvihill, CSSp. | 7/3/1966 | |
| Rev. Charles J. Murphy | Brooklyn | 6/6/1936 |
| Rev. Joseph P. Nagle | New York City | 5/29/1971 |
| Rev. Heebong Nam | ||
| Rev. John J. O’Brien | Brooklyn | 6/10/1922 |
| Rev. Francis P. O’Loughlen | Queens | 6/6/1936 |
| Rev. Edward J. O’Reilly | Astoria | 6/22/1917 |
| Rev. Michael Orsi | Brooklyn | 5/20/1976 |
| Rev. Philip J. Pizzo | Brooklyn | 6/4/1977 |
| Msgr. Arthur W. Pote | Manhattan | 10/18/1936 |
| Rev. John W. Powers | Massachusetts | 5/29/1926 |
| Rev. Peter C. Rassaerts | France | 6/29/1895 |
| Rev. Henry J. Reel | Brooklyn | 5/26/1934 |
| Rev. Bernard J. Reilly | Brooklyn | 7/27/1913 |
| Rev. Edmund J. Reilly | Manhattan | 1922 |
| Rev. James S. Reilly | Brooklyn | 6/6/1903 |
| Rev. Joseph D. Ryan | Ireland | 5/29/1921 |
| Rev. Jerome J. Schmidt | Brooklyn | 6/11/1949 |
| Rev. Donald F. Schwind | Brooklyn | 6/15/1946 |
| Rev. James Shanley, CSSp. | ||
| Rev. John P. Smith | New York City | 5/29/1920 |
| Rev. James E. Sullivan | Corona | 6/15/1946 |
| Rev. Kieran Udeze |